♥♦ Java abstract classes Vs interfaces

Q1. When to use an abstract class over an interface?
Q2. What is a diamond problem?
Q3. Does Java support multiple inheritance?

In design, you want the base class to present only an interface (or a contract) for its derived classes. This means, you don’t want anyone to actually instantiate an object of the base class. You only want to up cast to it (implicit up casting, which gives you polymorphic behavior), so that its interface can be used. This is accomplished by making that class abstract using the abstract keyword. If anyone tries to make an object of an abstract class, the compiler prevents it with a compile-time error.

Q. What is the purpose of an abstract class?
A. The purpose of abstract classes is to function as base classes which can be extended by sub classes to create a full implementation. The base class is used for code reuse and gives polymorphism by up casting to it.

Q. Should it have at least one abstract member?
A. It is subjective, but it is preferred. If your intention is to prevent a class from being instantiated, then the best way to handle this is with a private or protected constructor, and not by marking it abstract.

Q.Can you give an example of an abstract class where it is used prevalently?
A. Template Method design pattern is a good example of using an abstract class and this pattern is used very prevalently in application frameworks. The Template Method design pattern is about providing partial implementations in the abstract base classes, and the subclasses can complete when extending the Template Method base class(es). Here is an example

Another design pattern that makes use of abstract classes is the composite design pattern. A node or a component is the parent or base class and derivatives can either be leaves (singular), or collections of other nodes, which in turn can contain leaves or collection-nodes. When an operation is performed on the parent, that operation is recursively passed down the hierarchy. An interface can be used instead of an abstract class, but an abstract class can provide some default behavior for the add(), remove() and getChild() methods.

Composite design pattern

Composite design pattern



Java 8: If you are using Java 8 or later versions of Java, you can have default methods and static helper methods in Java 8 interface definition.


Q. What is the purpose of an interface?
A. The interface keyword takes this concept of an abstract class a step further where till Java 7, you can’t have implementations in an interface, but from Java 8 onwards, the concept of functional interfaces was introduced where you can implement default methods and static helper methods.

Q. What are the differences between abstract classes and interfaces?
A.

Before Java 8:

Abstract class Interface
Can maintain state in instance and static variables. No state.
Have executable methods and abstract methods. Have no implementation code. All methods are abstract.
Can only extend one abstract class.

public ClassB extends ClassA {}

A class can implement any number of interfaces.

public ClassB implements InterfaceA, InterfaceB{}

Java 8 onwards:

Abstract class Interface
Can maintain state in instance and static variables. No state.
Have executable methods and abstract methods. Have executable default methods and static helper methods.
Can only subclass one abstract class. A class can implement any number of interfaces.

So, from Java 8 onwards, the key difference is only one class can extend an abstract class, but a class can implement more than one interfaces.


Q. What is the diamond problem?
A. The diamond problem is that in the multiple-inheritance diagram on the left hand side below where CircleOnSquare inherits state and behavior from both Circle and Square. So, when we instantiate an object of class CircleOnSquare, any calls to method definitions in class Shape will be ambiguous – because it’s not sure whether to call the version of the method derived from class Circle or class Square.

Multiple inheritance and diamond issue

Multiple inheritance and diamond issue

Java does not have multiple inheritance, as you can only extend one class. This means that Java is not at risk of suffering the consequences of the diamond problem. But, Java does support multiple interface inheritance as shown above on the right hand side of the diagram as a Java class can implement multiple interfaces. Hang on!!!!! From Java 8 onwards, you can have functional interfaces where you can implement default and static methods. This means, Java supports multiple behavior inheritance, but not full multiple inheritance as state cannot be inherited because you can’t define instance variables in an interface.

Before Java 8 interface example:

After Java 8 interface example with default and static helper methods:


Now, if we have a class Calculator, which implements two functional interfaces Operation and Sum, and both has a default method add(Integer o). How does it know which default method to use? The one from Operation or the one from Sum. The Calculator class must solve the multiple behavior inheritance ambiguity by throwing a compile-time error

java: class Impl inherits unrelated defaults for add(Integer o) from types Operation and Sum.

In order to fix this class, the Calculator class needs to implement the add(Integer o) method to resolve the ambiguity.


Q. When to use an abstract class over an interface?
A.

Abstract classes

With the advent of Default Methods in Java 8, it seems that Interfaces and abstract Classes are same as you can implement behavior in both. However, they are still different concepts as

  • An Abstract Class can define constructor(s).
  • Abstract classes are more structured and can have a state associated with them. While in contrast, default method can be implemented only in the terms of invoking other Interface methods, with no reference to a particular implementation’s state.

Hence, both are used for different purposes and choosing between two really depends on the scenario. Abstract methods are good for implementing template method and composite design patterns with state and behavior.

Interfaces

If you need to change your design frequently, you should prefer using interfaces to abstract classes. Coding to an interface reduces coupling and interface inheritance can achieve code reuse with the help of object composition. For example: The Spring frameworks’ dependency injection promotes code to an interface principle. Another justification for using interfaces is that they solve the ‘diamond problem’ of traditional multiple inheritance. Java does not support multiple inheritance, but supports multiple behavior inheritance.

Strategy design pattern lets you swap new algorithms and processes into your program without altering the objects that use them by making use of interfaces.

Q. What are the different ways to get code reuse?
A. There are 3 approaches

1. Implementation inheritance with abstract classes.
2. Composition.
3. Delegation to a helper class.

Implementation inheritance gives you polymorphism in addition to code reuse. You can up cast your child class to your abstract base class. If you are using composition for code reuse, then you need to use behavior inheritance with interfaces to get polymorphism (i.e. code to interface).

The GoF design patterns favor composition for code reuse with polymorphism with interfaces over implementation inheritance with abstract classes for code reuse and poylmorphism.

Why?

1. Code reuse via composition happens at run time whereas code reuse via inheritance happens at compile time. Hence, composition is more flexible and less fragile.

2. It is easy to misuse inheritance when there is really no “is a” relationship, hence breaking the Lithkov’s Substitution Principle (LSP). For example, a square is not a rectangle. Overuse of implementation inheritance (uses the “extends” key word) can break all the sub classes, if the super class is modified. Do not use inheritance just to get polymorphism. If there is no ‘is a’ relationship and all you want is polymorphism then use interface inheritance with composition, which gives you code reuse.

3. Composition offers better testability than Inheritance. Composition is easier to test because inheritance tends to create very coupled classes that are more fragile (i.e. fragile parent class) and harder to test in isolation. The IoC containers like Spring, make testing even easier through injecting the composed objects via constructor or setter injection.

Why favor composition over inheritance? detailed discussion.

Q. What is the difference between the default methods introduced in Java 8 and regular methods?
A. In summary, default methods are like regular methods, but

  • the default methods come with the default modifier.
  • the default methods can only access its arguments as Interfaces do not have any state.

Regular methods in Classes can use and modify method arguments as well as the variables (i.e state) of their Class.

The default (aka defender) methods allow you to add new methods to interfaces without breaking the existing implementations of your interfaces. This provides an added flexibility by allowing interfaces to provide default implementations in situations where concrete classes fail to provide implementations for a methods.

Print Friendly
The following two tabs change content below.
Arulkumaran Kumaraswamipillai
Mechanical Engineering to Java freelancer since 2003. Published Java/JEE books via Amazon.com in 2005, and sold 35K+ copies. Books are outdated and replaced with this online Java training.
Arulkumaran Kumaraswamipillai

Mechanical Engineering to Java freelancer since 2003. Published Java/JEE books via Amazon.com in 2005, and sold 35K+ copies. Books are outdated and replaced with this online Java training.

Posted in Classes

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

1100+ paid subscribers. Reviews | Free Contents. Monthly 260K+ views & 40k+ visitors. 9 tips to earn more.

Java Developer Training – 800+ Q&As ♥Free|♦FAQ (Mouse Hover for Tooltip)

open all | close all

200+ Java Developer Job Interview FAQs

open all | close all

16 Java Programmer Key Areas to be a top-notch

open all | close all

80+ Java Tutorials – Step by step

open all | close all

100+ Java Developer Coding Exercises

open all | close all

How good are your …..Java job hunting & career fast-tracking skills?

open all | close all